Which of the following should be considered as gender neutral atmosphere in a…
2024
Which of the following should be considered as gender neutral atmosphere in a school?
(a) A group of girls are making Rangoli
(b) A group of boys are volunteering in annual function.
(c) A group of girls are preparing for dance competition.
(d) A group of boys are arranging refreshments for guests.
Choose the correct option:
- A.
(a) and (b)
- B.
(b) and (c)
- C.
(a) and (c)
- D.
(b) and (d)
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: D
Concept: A gender-neutral school atmosphere is one where an activity is not treated as belonging naturally to one gender. A group performing a task that runs counter to that task's conventional gender-coding is evidence AGAINST gender-based typecasting; a group performing a task that matches its conventional gender-coding is, on its own, not such evidence -- it is simply consistent with the existing stereotype and does not by itself show the school has moved away from it.
Application: Rangoli-making and preparing for a dance competition are cultural/artistic activities conventionally coded as suited to girls in Indian schools; a group of girls performing these activities is consistent with that existing coding and does not by itself demonstrate a gender-neutral practice. Arranging refreshments for guests is a hospitality/service task conventionally coded as suited to girls or women; here it is a group of boys performing it, alongside volunteering in the annual function -- so this depicts boys taking up a task that runs counter to its conventional gender-coding, which is what counts as evidence of a gender-neutral practice.
Cross-check -- reading each combination on this test:
(a) and (b): pairs an activity that matches its conventional gender-coding (girls doing Rangoli) with one where boys take up an event duty (volunteering) -- a mixed picture, not a consistent instance of gender-neutral practice.
(b) and (c): again mixes boys taking up an event duty (volunteering) with an activity that matches its conventional gender-coding (girls preparing for the dance competition) -- also a mixed picture.
(a) and (c): both activities depict girls performing tasks that match their conventional gender-coding (Rangoli and dance) -- consistent with, rather than counter to, the existing stereotype.
(b) and (d): both activities depict boys performing tasks, including the hospitality-type duty of arranging refreshments, which runs counter to that task's conventional gender-coding -- so together this is the pair that counters gender-based typecasting.
Result: The pairing of boys volunteering in the annual function with boys arranging refreshments for guests is the combination that runs counter to conventional gender-coding, making (b) and (d) the option that reflects a gender-neutral school atmosphere.