When inference is based not on causation but on uniformity of co-existence, as…
2023
When inference is based not on causation but on uniformity of co-existence, as in inferring the cloven hoofs of an animal from its horns, what is it called?
Answer: C. Sāmānyatodṛṣṭa — ConceptIn Nyāya, anumāna can be classified by the relation linking the observed sign to what is inferred. Pūrvavat and Śeṣavat use a cause–effect direction,…
- A.
Pūrvavat Anumāna
- B.
Śeṣavat Anumāna
- C.
Sāmānyatodṛṣṭa
- D.
Pakṣadharmatā
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: C
Concept
In Nyāya, anumāna can be classified by the relation linking the observed sign to what is inferred.
Pūrvavat and Śeṣavat use a cause–effect direction, whereas Sāmānyatodṛṣṭa rests on regular association or co-existence without treating either feature as the cause of the other.
Application
The example moves from horns to cloven hoofs. These are co-existing animal features; the inference does not proceed from a cause to its effect or from an effect back to its cause.
Contrast
Pūrvavat Anumāna infers an unobserved effect from an observed cause, such as future rain from dark clouds.
Śeṣavat Anumāna infers an unobserved cause from an observed effect, such as past rain from a swollen muddy river.
Pakṣadharmatā is the condition that the reason or sign is present in the subject under consideration; it is not a type in this threefold causal-relation classification.
Cross-check
The stated link is regular co-existence and is explicitly not causation, so it fits Sāmānyatodṛṣṭa.
Result
Therefore, the answer is Sāmānyatodṛṣṭa.