P : "Program is a step by step execution of the instructions". Given P, which…
2009
P : "Program is a step by step execution of the instructions". Given P, which of the following is true?
Answer: B. Program is a sequence of a subset of an instruction set. — Concept: A program is being characterized here in terms of set/order structures on the instruction set. A plain set only records membership (which…
- A.
Program is a subset of an instruction set.
- B.
Program is a sequence of a subset of an instruction set.
- C.
Program is a partially ordered set of an instruction set.
- D.
All of the above
Attempted by 176 students.
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: B
Concept: A program is being characterized here in terms of set/order structures on the instruction set. A plain set only records membership (which instructions occur) and carries no notion of order among its elements. A partially ordered set (poset) imposes some precedence between elements, but permits pairs that remain incomparable -- no forced before/after relation is required between every pair. A sequence (a totally ordered list) is stronger than both: on a reading where the program is treated as a sequence, most elements have a definite predecessor and successor (only the first and last steps lack one on each side), fixing one specific execution order rather than merely permitting one.
Application: Statement P describes a program as a "step by step execution of the instructions." One reading takes this as two requirements together: the program draws from a defined portion of the instructions available in the full instruction set, and it fixes one definite order in which those instructions are carried out, one step following the next (a sequence, not merely an unordered set). Under that reading, the option naming both properties together -- a subset arranged as a sequence -- best matches P's "step by step" phrasing; note, however, that the underlying set of an ordered sequence is technically also a partially ordered set (a total order is a special case of a partial order), which is why this item's option set is debated among solved-paper sources rather than settled by an official key.
Cross-check: Checking each remaining option against the concept shows why the reasoning is close, not clear-cut:
Describing a program only as a subset of the instruction set records which instructions are used but says nothing about their execution order by itself, so read alone it does not capture "step by step."
Describing a program as a partially ordered set of the instruction set is technically compatible with a strict one-after-another order (since a total order is one kind of partial order), which is exactly the technicality that makes this item's intended single answer disputed across sources.
Because a sequence is itself a special case of a partially-ordered set, and its underlying instructions form a subset, more than one option can be argued to hold simultaneously depending on how strictly "is" is read -- which is why this item is flagged for expert adjudication rather than resolved definitively here.
Result: The best-supported single reading combines a subset of the instruction set with a definite step-by-step (sequential) execution order -- i.e., a program is a sequence of a subset of an instruction set -- but because reputable solved-paper sources diverge on this exact item (some select this option, others select "all of the above"), and no official answer key could be located, the key is being routed for expert confirmation rather than asserted with full confidence.