K introduces N to his friend, saying, “He is the husband of the granddaughter…
2024
K introduces N to his friend, saying, “He is the husband of the granddaughter of the father of my father.” The granddaughter mentioned is a child of K’s father. How is N related to K?
Answer: D. Brother-in-law — ConceptIn a family-relation chain, begin with the speaker and resolve each phrase from the inside outward. Keep blood relations separate from relations…
- A.
Brother
- B.
Son-in-law
- C.
Nephew
- D.
Brother-in-law
Attempted by 2 students.
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: D
Concept
In a family-relation chain, begin with the speaker and resolve each phrase from the inside outward. Keep blood relations separate from relations created by marriage.
A person married to one’s sister is called a brother-in-law. This differs from a brother, nephew, or son-in-law because each follows a different generational or marital link.
Application
The father of K’s father is K’s paternal grandfather.
The stem specifies that the granddaughter is a child of K’s father. Because K is male and this child is female, she is K’s sister.
N is the husband of that granddaughter, so N is the husband of K’s sister.
Contrast
Brother: a male sibling of K, involving no marriage link.
Son-in-law: the husband of K’s daughter, one generation below K.
Nephew: the son of K’s sibling, one generation below K.
Brother-in-law: the husband of K’s sister, which is the relation formed here.
Cross-check and result
Reading the chain in reverse, K is a sibling of N’s wife. Therefore N’s relation to K is brother-in-law.