A girl introduced a boy as the son of the daughter of the father of her uncle.…
2015
A girl introduced a boy as the son of the daughter of the father of her uncle. The boy is related to the girl as :
Answer: A. Brother — Concept — A relation written as "the A of the B of the C of X" is resolved from the innermost person outwards: settle the last-named person first, then apply…
- A.
Brother
- B.
Uncle
- C.
Nephew
- D.
Son
Attempted by 11 students.
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: A
Concept — A relation written as "the A of the B of the C of X" is resolved from the innermost person outwards: settle the last-named person first, then apply each preceding relation one link at a time, recording each new person’s generation level and gender on the family tree until the outermost relation is reached.
Application
Innermost person: “her uncle”. Take him as a brother of the girl’s mother, that is, her maternal uncle.
“The father of her uncle”: the father of that maternal uncle is the girl’s maternal grandfather.
“The daughter of the father of her uncle”: a daughter of that grandfather is a sister of the uncle, that is, the girl’s own mother.
“The son of the daughter of the father of her uncle”: a son of the girl’s mother is a male child of the same mother as the girl. That makes the boy her brother.
Cross-check
Read the chain backwards to confirm it closes: her brother is a son of her mother; her mother is a daughter of her maternal grandfather; her maternal grandfather is the father of her uncle.
Test the other reading of “uncle”: if he were her father’s brother, that father would be her paternal grandfather, his daughter would be the girl’s paternal aunt, and that aunt’s son would be the girl’s cousin, a relation the given choices do not contain. Only the maternal reading yields a relation that appears among the choices, so that is the intended reading.
The boy is therefore the girl’s brother.