Seven boxes A, B, C, D, E, F and G are kept one over the other but not…
2025
Seven boxes A, B, C, D, E, F and G are kept one over the other but not necessarily in the same order. Only four boxes are kept between G and A. Only C is kept above G. Only two boxes are kept between B and F. D is kept immediately above E. F is not kept immediately above D. How many boxes are kept above E?
- A.
5
- B.
3
- C.
4
- D.
2
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: C
Concept
In a floor/level-based (vertical stacking) arrangement, all seven boxes occupy one fixed column of positions. A clue phrased as "only K boxes are between/above X" pins an exact position once combined with the total box count, while "immediately above/below" and "K boxes between" clues fix relative order among the remaining boxes. Solve by anchoring every exact-position clue first, then testing each valid relative-order combination against the remaining clues to eliminate all but one arrangement.
Application
Fix the seven positions from bottom (1) to top (7).
"Only C is kept above G" means exactly one box sits above G, so G occupies position 6 and C occupies position 7 (the topmost slot).
"Only four boxes are kept between G and A" means the positions of G and A differ by 5 (4 boxes strictly between them, plus 1 more step). With G at position 6, A must be at position 1 (position 11 does not exist).
The remaining boxes B, D, E and F now occupy positions 2, 3, 4 and 5 in some order.
"D is kept immediately above E" restricts D and E to one of three adjacent pairs within {2, 3, 4, 5}: (E=2, D=3), (E=3, D=4), or (E=4, D=5).
"Only two boxes are kept between B and F" means the positions of B and F differ by 3. Testing (E=2, D=3) leaves {4, 5} for B and F — a difference of only 1, so this pair fails. Testing (E=4, D=5) leaves {2, 3} for B and F — again a difference of only 1, so this pair also fails.
Only (E=3, D=4) survives: it leaves {2, 5} for B and F, and 5 − 2 = 3, satisfying the "two boxes between B and F" clue.
"F is not kept immediately above D" rules out F occupying position 5 (which would be immediately above D at position 4). So F takes position 2, and B takes the remaining position 5.
The complete order from bottom to top is: A (1), F (2), E (3), D (4), B (5), G (6), C (7).
Cross-check
G (position 6) and A (position 1): the boxes at positions 2–5 (F, E, D, B) sit between them — exactly four, matching the first clue.
Above G (position 6): only position 7 (C) — matching the second clue.
B (position 5) and F (position 2): the boxes at positions 3–4 (E, D) sit between them — exactly two, matching the third clue.
D (position 4) is immediately above E (position 3), matching the fourth clue.
F (position 2) is two positions below D (position 4), so F is not immediately above D — matching the fifth clue.
Result
E is at position 3, so the boxes above E are D, B, G and C — 4 boxes.