If J + K means J is the brother of K, J × K means J is the mother of K, and J…
2023
If J + K means J is the brother of K, J × K means J is the mother of K, and J / K means J is the sister of K, then which of the following states that C is the uncle of D?
- A.
C / D + A
- B.
C × D + A
- C.
C × A + D
- D.
C + A × D
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: D
In these coded relation puzzles, the operators are fixed: '+' = brother, '×' = mother, and '/' = sister, always read as "first person [operator] second person". An uncle of a person X is the brother of one of X's parents — so, structurally, the coded statement for "P is the uncle of X" must be a two-step chain of exactly this shape: P + Y (P is the brother of some connecting person Y) followed by Y × X (Y is the mother of X), sharing the same middle person Y. Any other operator order or combination encodes a different relationship — direct sibling, direct parent, or something else — not an uncle.
Each option chains two relations through a shared middle letter — read left to right, evaluate the first operator between the first two letters, then the second operator between the last two letters.
C / D + A: the first relation, C / D, already states C is the sister of D — a direct sibling relation to D.
C × D + A: the first relation, C × D, already states C is the mother of D — a direct parent relation to D.
C × A + D: the first relation, C × A, states C is the mother of A; the second, A + D, states A is the brother of D, so A and D are siblings — making C a parent of D as well.
C + A × D: the first relation, C + A, states C is the brother of A; the second, A × D, states A is the mother of D — so C is the brother of D's mother.
Only the chain C + A × D matches the required brother-then-mother pattern through the same connecting person, and the genders stay consistent throughout (C stays male via '+', matching 'uncle').
Contrast:
C / D + A makes C a sibling of D, not the brother of D's parent.
C × D + A makes C the parent of D directly, not the parent's brother.
C × A + D makes C a parent of D (via the shared sibling A), not the sibling of D's parent.
Therefore, the expression C + A × D is the one that correctly states C is the uncle of D.