Under the Constitution of India, in which named constitutional category is the…

2023

Under the Constitution of India, in which named constitutional category is the ‘freedom of silence’ specifically protected?

Answer: C. The Fundamental RightsConceptFundamental rights are constitutionally guaranteed freedoms contained in Part III of the Constitution of India. Article 19(1)(a) protects freedom of…

  1. A.

    The Legal Rights

  2. B.

    The Social Rights

  3. C.

    The Fundamental Rights

  4. D.

    More than one of the above

  5. E.

    None of the above

Attempted by 5 students.

Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: C

Concept

Fundamental rights are constitutionally guaranteed freedoms contained in Part III of the Constitution of India. Article 19(1)(a) protects freedom of speech and expression.

Freedom of expression also has a negative dimension: a person may choose not to speak or otherwise express a message.

Application

In Bijoe Emmanuel v. State of Kerala, students stood respectfully during the National Anthem but declined to sing because of their conscientious religious belief. The Supreme Court held that compelling them to sing would violate Article 19(1)(a), along with Article 25(1).

Contrast

  • The term “legal rights” is a broad umbrella covering rights recognized by law, including statutory and constitutional rights.

  • The term “social rights” is a descriptive label for welfare or participation entitlements, not the constitutional classification used here.

  • More than one of the above would require two distinct listed classifications to be the intended answer.

  • None of the above would apply only if no listed constitutional classification fit.

Cross-check

Article 19 is located in Part III, and Part III is titled Fundamental Rights. The judicial protection of silence under Article 19 therefore confirms the classification.

Therefore, the freedom of silence is a fundamental right.

Explore the full course: Bpsc

Loading lesson…