Daksh is taller than Manick but not as tall as Rohan. Somesh is shorter than…
2024
Daksh is taller than Manick but not as tall as Rohan. Somesh is shorter than Daksh but taller than Farhan. Who among them is the shortest?
- A.
Daksh
- B.
Manick
- C.
Farhan
- D.
Cannot be determined
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: D
Concept: In a ranking/ordering puzzle, convert each comparative sentence into an inequality chain, then merge the chains that share a common person. Two people can only be ranked against each other if some chain, directly or transitively, connects them — if no such link exists, their relative order, and hence which of them is the overall extreme (tallest/shortest), stays undetermined.
Application:
From “Daksh is taller than Manick but not as tall as Rohan”: Rohan > Daksh > Manick.
From “Somesh is shorter than Daksh but taller than Farhan”: Daksh > Somesh > Farhan.
Merging the two chains on the shared person Daksh gives Rohan > Daksh, with Daksh > Manick on one branch and Daksh > Somesh > Farhan on another branch.
No statement links Manick to Somesh or to Farhan, so Manick's position relative to that second branch cannot be fixed — he could sit above Somesh, between Somesh and Farhan, or below Farhan.
Cross-check: each of the orderings below is fully consistent with both given statements:
Rohan > Daksh > Manick > Somesh > Farhan (Farhan is last)
Rohan > Daksh > Somesh > Manick > Farhan (Farhan is last)
Rohan > Daksh > Somesh > Farhan > Manick (Manick is last)
Since the last-placed person changes across these equally valid orderings, the shortest person cannot be determined from the given information.