Select the option that completes the sentence CORRECTLY. Whilst one group was…
2017
Select the option that completes the sentence CORRECTLY. Whilst one group was busy cooking, the other ________ wood for the campfire.
- A.
collected
- B.
will collect
- C.
is collecting
- D.
has collected
Attempted by 3 students.
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: A
Concept
When two actions happen in the same past time frame, English keeps their tenses in agreement (the sequence-of-tenses rule). If the framing clause is in the past, the action that goes with it in the same narrative is normally in the simple past too — not in the present or the future, which would point to a different time.
Application
The framing clause here is "Whilst one group was busy cooking" — "was" fixes the whole sentence in the past. The blank describes a second action by the other group happening in that same past time, so it must be a finite verb in the simple past:
"Whilst one group was busy cooking, the other collected wood for the campfire."
Contrast with the other forms
"will collect" is the simple future — it places the action ahead of now, which clashes with the past framing "was busy".
"is collecting" is the present continuous — it describes an action going on now, again out of step with the past clause.
"has collected" is the present perfect — it links a past action to the present moment, but here the time is fully past and parallel to "was cooking", so the plain simple past is what fits.
The simple-past form that matches the past time frame is the correct completion.