A sentence is provided in indirect speech. From the four given options, choose…
2025
A sentence is provided in indirect speech. From the four given options, choose the one that most accurately conveys the sentence in its corresponding direct speech.
The librarian said that silence must be maintained in the library.
Answer: C. "Maintain silence in the library," said the librarian. — Concept: Converting reported speech back into direct speech has to preserve three things at once — the type of the sentence (statement, command or question),…
- A.
"Silence should be maintained in the library," said the librarian.
- B.
"You will maintain silence in the library," the librarian said.
- C.
"Maintain silence in the library," said the librarian.
- D.
"Must you maintain silence in the library?" asked the librarian.
Attempted by 1 students.
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: C
Concept: Converting reported speech back into direct speech has to preserve three things at once — the type of the sentence (statement, command or question), the strength of the modal, and the speaker's purpose. A reported clause of obligation does not by itself fix one single original wording: a duty laid down by an authority may have been spoken either as a declarative carrying the modal or as an imperative, and English expresses a directive in direct speech as an imperative — the base form of the verb, with the subject 'you' understood rather than written. When more than one form could have produced the report, the accurate direct rendering is the one that keeps the modal at its original strength and keeps the same people addressed.
Application: The reporting clause here is “The librarian said that silence must be maintained in the library.” The librarian is the authority of that room, 'must' is the strongest obligation modal in English, and the duty falls on the people using the library, so what was spoken carried the force of an instruction. The fully literal direct rendering would be “Silence must be maintained in the library,” said the librarian — but that form is not offered, and the stem asks for the option that conveys the sentence MOST ACCURATELY among those given. That option is the imperative “Maintain silence in the library,” said the librarian: of the four, it alone keeps the obligation at full strength and keeps it aimed at the library's users, differing from the literal rendering only in construction, not in force.
Contrast: Each of the other renderings loses more than a change of construction:
“Silence should be maintained in the library” keeps the statement shape but exchanges 'must' for 'should'. 'Should' expresses advisability — something recommended, which the hearer may reasonably decline — while 'must' records a binding requirement.
“You will maintain silence in the library” turns the obligation into 'will', an assertion about what a named addressee is going to do at a future time. A prediction or an assurance is not the duty the original records.
“Must you maintain silence in the library?” moves the modal in front of the subject to build a question, which asks the hearer for information. The original reports something the librarian said, not something the librarian asked.
Cross-check: Check each option by reporting it back with a plain reporting verb and seeing how far the result drifts from the sentence we were given. The imperative would ordinarily be reported with a directive construction — “told them to maintain silence” — so it drifts in construction, but its obligation is undiminished and still aimed at the library's users. The other three drift in meaning: “Silence should be maintained” reports back with a weakened obligation, “You will maintain silence” reports back as a statement about what someone was going to do, and the interrogative reports back as “asked whether they had to maintain silence”, a question rather than something said. Only the imperative leaves the force of 'must' intact, which is why it is the closest of the four.