Read the following statements and select the correct option. Assertion (A):…

2024

Read the following statements and select the correct option.

Assertion (A): Dried raisins when left in plain water for some time swell due to osmosis.
Reason (R): Plant cells have a selectively permeable cell membrane.

  1. A.

    (A) and (R) are both correct and (R) is the correct explanation for (A).

  2. B.

    (A) and (R) are both correct but (R) is not the correct explanation for (A).

  3. C.

    (A) is correct but (R) is incorrect.

  4. D.

    (A) is incorrect but (R) is correct.

Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: A

Osmosis is the net movement of water molecules through a selectively permeable membrane - one that lets water pass while restricting the movement of larger dissolved solutes - from a region of higher water concentration to a region of lower water concentration, until the system approaches equilibrium.

Dried raisins hold a concentrated cell sap with very little free water, so their cells are hypertonic relative to plain water. When raisins are soaked in water, the plant cell's plasma membrane - being selectively permeable - lets water molecules enter the cells while holding back the dissolved sugars inside. This net inward movement of water increases cell volume and the raisin visibly swells; this is a standard demonstration of osmosis.

The claim that plant cells possess a selectively permeable membrane is a well-established biological fact, and it is exactly this selective permeability that is the causal mechanism enabling the water uptake just described: without it, either no controlled water movement would occur (an impermeable membrane) or solutes would leak out along with water entering (a fully permeable membrane), and the clean water-only inflow that causes swelling would not happen. So the membrane property is not a coincidental fact sitting beside the swelling observation - it directly explains why the swelling happens.

  • Two statements about the same phenomenon can each be independently true without being unrelated - selective permeability is exactly the property that supplies the causal mechanism for the water movement, so the explanatory link holds.

  • A membrane being selectively permeable is a standard, verified property of plant cells, not a false claim - it lets water pass while regulating solute movement.

  • Placing dehydrated fruit such as raisins in plain water is a directly observable process, not a false premise - the fruit visibly swells as water enters the hypertonic cells, exactly as osmosis predicts.

Explore the full course: Uptet Paper 1

Loading lesson…