Which statement is incorrect about the development and its relationship with…

2024

Which statement is incorrect about the development and its relationship with learning?

  1. A.

    Deprivation of learning opportunities limits development.

  2. B.

    Children can not learn until they are developmentally ready to learn.

  3. C.

    Development is the product of maturation and learning.

  4. D.

    Despite the limits of maturation the development can go beyond a certain point, when learning is encouraged.

Attempted by 34 students.

Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: D

Concept: Development is the sequential, qualitative change an organism undergoes across the lifespan and is standardly explained as the joint outcome of two processes: Maturation (the genetically-timed, biologically-programmed unfolding of structures and capacities, largely independent of specific training) and Learning (relatively permanent changes in behaviour or understanding produced by experience and practice). Maturation sets readiness and an upper ceiling: a capacity can be learned only once the underlying structures have matured, and however rich the learning experience, development cannot be pushed past the limit that maturation has set at a given stage. Learning is what allows a child to reach that ceiling -- withholding learning opportunities keeps development below its maturational potential.

Application: Checking each statement against this principle:

  • Deprivation of learning limiting development fits the concept directly: learning is needed to realise the potential maturation has made available, so its absence keeps development below that potential -- a correct description, not the incorrect one.

  • Children being unable to learn until developmentally ready restates the readiness principle -- maturation is a precondition learning must wait on -- a correct description, not the incorrect one.

  • Development being the joint product of maturation and learning is the definition itself -- a correct description, not the incorrect one.

  • The claim that development can go beyond the limits of maturation once learning is encouraged reverses the direction of the relationship: the accepted position is that maturation caps development, and no amount of learning support moves that cap. This statement contradicts the standard principle, making it the incorrect one among those offered.

Cross-check: A classic illustration is Gesell's co-twin control study on stair-climbing -- a twin given early practice showed no lasting advantage once the untrained twin reached the same maturational stage, because practice could not push the skill past what maturation allowed at that age. This confirms the ceiling maturation sets cannot be exceeded through learning, reinforcing that the statement asserting the opposite is the incorrect one.

Explore the full course: Uptet Paper 1

Loading lesson…