Decide which argument(s) is/are 'strong' in the context of the given…
2016
Decide which argument(s) is/are 'strong' in the context of the given statement.
Statement : Should all school teachers be banned from giving private tuition?
logic :
I. Yes, now the salaries of these teachers are reasonable.
II. No, needy students will be deprived of the expertise of these teachers.
III. Yes, only then the quality of teaching in schools will improve.
- A.
Only II and III are strong
- B.
Only I and II are strong
- C.
Only III is strong
- D.
Only II is strong
Attempted by 36 students.
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: D
1. Analyze Argument I: It is weak because salary levels do not logically dictate whether a professional can offer private services.
2. Analyze Argument II: It is strong because it points out a genuine disadvantage for needy students who might require specialized extra help.
3. Analyze Argument III: It is weak because it uses the extreme word 'only', assuming no other methods can improve school teaching quality.
Final Answer: Option D