Decide which of the arguments given below is/are strong with respect to the…

2016

Decide which of the arguments given below is/are strong with respect to the following statement.

Statement: Should the system of Lok Adalats and Night Courts be encouraged in India?

Arguments:
I. No, generally these courts are not fully capable of delivering justice.
II. Yes, they help common people get quick justice.
III. Yes, this will especially reduce the burden on higher courts in small cases.

  1. A.

    Only argument I is strong.

  2. B.

    Only arguments I and III are strong.

  3. C.

    Only arguments II and III are strong.

  4. D.

    All are strong.

Attempted by 5 students.

Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: C

1. Evaluate Argument I: Stating that Lok Adalats and Night Courts are not capable of delivering justice is an unsubstantiated, sweeping negative claim. These statutory bodies operate under proper legal frameworks, making this argument weak. 2. Evaluate Argument II: This argument highlights a positive and practical advantage. Lok Adalats explicitly focus on conciliatory settlements, which fundamentally provide quick and affordable justice to common citizens. Thus, it is strong. 3. Evaluate Argument III: Resolving petty and minor civil disputes at local levels naturally checks the influx of litigation into high courts or district courts. This highlights a critical relief mechanism for the judiciary, making it strong. 4. Since arguments II and III are logically sound and directly link to systemic improvements, Option C is the correct choice. Final Answer: Option C

Explore the full course: Up Police Computer Operator