Each question given below consists of a statement, followed by two arguments…
2017
Each question given below consists of a statement, followed by two arguments numbered I and II. You have to decide which of the arguments is a 'strong' argument and which is a 'weak' argument.
Statement: Student Union plays an important role in college/university.
Arguments:
I. Student Union creates a political atmosphere in the campus and it is helpful to develop the leadership quality.
II. Students can become future political leaders.
- A.
Only argument I is strong
- B.
Both I and II are strong
- C.
Only argument II is strong
- D.
Either I or II is strong
Attempted by 26 students.
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: B
To determine the strength of the arguments, we must evaluate whether they directly and logically support the statement: "Student Union plays an important role in college/university."
Argument Analysis
Argument I: "Student Union creates a political atmosphere in the campus and it is helpful to develop the leadership quality."
Assessment: This is a strong argument. It provides a direct reason for the "important role" mentioned in the statement by highlighting specific, positive outcomes (political awareness and leadership development) that directly impact the student experience.
Argument II: "Students can become future political leaders."
Assessment: This is also a strong argument. It supports the statement by identifying a long-term, significant impact of student unions: they serve as a training ground for future leadership in society and governance.
Conclusion
Both arguments provide valid, rational support for the importance of student unions. Therefore, Option 2 (Both I and II are strong) is the correct answer.