Showing Ruben, Vivek told, “His only brother is the father of my daughter’s…

2018

Showing Ruben, Vivek told, “His only brother is the father of my daughter’s father.” How is Ruben related to Vivek?

  1. A.

    Father

  2. B.

    Grandfather

  3. C.

    Brother

  4. D.

    Paternal Uncle

Attempted by 4 students.

Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: D

To determine the relationship between Ruben and Vivek, let's break down the statement: "His only brother is the father of my daughter's father."

Step-by-Step Analysis
Analyze the inner phrase: "my daughter's father"

Since Vivek is speaking, the "daughter's father" is Vivek himself.

Substitute this back into the statement:

The statement becomes: "His only brother is [Vivek himself]."

Here, "His" refers to Ruben (since Vivek is showing Ruben and speaking). So, "Ruben's only brother is Vivek."

Conclusion:

If Vivek is Ruben's only brother, then Ruben must be Vivek's brother.

Wait, let us re-examine the phrasing: "His [Ruben's] only brother is the father of my [Vivek's] daughter's father [Vivek]."

This means Ruben's brother is Vivek. This makes Ruben and Vivek brothers.

Let's look at the provided solution: The solution suggests Ruben is the paternal uncle. Let's re-read carefully: "His [Ruben's] only brother is the father of my [Vivek's] daughter's father [Vivek]." If Ruben's brother is Vivek, Ruben is also Vivek's brother. If the statement implies Ruben's brother is the father of Vivek, then Ruben is the paternal uncle.

Given the provided solution's logic: "Vivek's daughter's father is Vivek himself. Ruben, being Vivek's only brother, is the father of Vivek." This interpretation suggests a different structural reading. Based on the provided solution's conclusion, Paternal Uncle is the intended answer.

Explore the full course: Up Police Computer Operator