The given question consists of a statement, followed by two arguments numbered…
202520242025
The given question consists of a statement, followed by two arguments numbered I and II. You have to decide which of the argument(s) is(are) 'strong' and accordingly select the correct option.
Statement:
Should seniority be only criteria for promotion?
Arguments:
I. No, it would be an injustice to those juniors who are more deserving and suitable for higher position.
II. Yes, otherwise seniors will feel humiliated .
- A.
Only I is strong
- B.
Only II is strong
- C.
Neither I nor II is strong
- D.
Both I and II is strong
Attempted by 223 students.
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: A
Answer: Only I is strong.
Evaluation of the arguments:
Argument I is strong: It points out that using only seniority for promotion can be unjust to juniors who are more deserving and better suited for the role. This is a logical and relevant concern because promotions affect organizational performance and fairness.
Argument II is weak: Claiming that seniors will feel humiliated is speculative and appeals to emotion. It does not provide a logical reason to make seniority the sole criterion and does not address merit, suitability, or organizational outcomes.
Conclusion:
Promotions should consider merit and suitability in addition to seniority to ensure fairness and effectiveness.
A video solution is available for this question — log in and enroll to watch it.