Directions: Select the correct passive form of the given sentence. People say…
20242023
Directions: Select the correct passive form of the given sentence.
People say he has lived on a liquid diet for years.
- A.
He is said to have lived on a liquid diet for years.
- B.
He is said to live on a liquid diet for years.
- C.
He has said to have lived on a liquid diet for years.
- D.
He is said to have been living on a liquid diet for years.
Attempted by 449 students.
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: A
Solution
Correct sentence: He is said to have lived on a liquid diet for years.
Key points
Identify the clauses: 'People say' is the reporting clause in the present simple; 'he has lived on a liquid diet for years' is the reported clause in the present perfect.
When forming the passive with reporting verbs like 'say', keep the reporting verb passive ('is said') and convert the reported perfect clause into the perfect infinitive ('to have' + past participle) to preserve the original aspect.
Therefore, the correct passive is: He is said to have lived on a liquid diet for years.
Why the other choices are wrong
Using 'is said to live' (simple infinitive) does not preserve the present perfect aspect of the original ('has lived').
Using 'has said' with 'he' makes 'he' the reporter, which changes the meaning and is not the intended passive transformation.
Using 'is said to have been living' changes the aspect to perfect continuous, adding an ongoing nuance that is not required by the original simple perfect form.
Final answer: He is said to have lived on a liquid diet for years.
A video solution is available for this question — log in and enroll to watch it.