Statements: Some kings are queens. All queens are beautiful. Conclusions: All…

2024

Statements:

Some kings are queens.

All queens are beautiful.

Conclusions:

All kings are beautiful.

All queens are kings.

  1. A.

    Only conclusion I follows

  2. B.

    Only conclusion II follows

  3. C.

    Either I or II follows

  4. D.

    Neither I nor II follows

Attempted by 44 students.

Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: D

Concept: In syllogisms, if either premise is particular (an "I" or "O" statement, e.g. "Some X are Y") rather than universal, any conclusion that validly follows must also be particular — a universal conclusion can never be drawn from a pair containing a particular premise. Also, a particular statement such as "Some X are Y" converts only to "Some Y are X", never to the universal "All Y are X" (that reversal is an illicit conversion).

Application:

  1. "Some kings are queens" is particular (an I-type statement, since it says only 'some').

  2. "All queens are beautiful" is universal (an A-type statement).

  3. Because one premise is particular, only a particular conclusion could ever be validly drawn from this pair — combining them through the shared middle term 'queens' would give something like "Some kings are beautiful", a particular claim. Neither conclusion offered here is that.

  4. Conclusion I, "All kings are beautiful", is universal, so it can never validly follow when one of the two premises is particular — it fails on form alone.

  5. Conclusion II, "All queens are kings", tries to reverse "Some kings are queens" into a universal claim about every queen; a particular premise reverses only to another particular statement ("Some queens are kings"), never to a universal one, so this is also invalid.

Cross-check: Let kings = {A, B, C} and queens = {B, D}, with B the one king who is also a queen (this satisfies "some kings are queens"). Let B and D (every queen) be beautiful, satisfying the second premise. Now let A and C (kings who are not queens) not be beautiful — "all kings are beautiful" is false. And D is a queen who is not a king — "all queens are kings" is false too. This single model satisfies both premises while making both conclusions false, so neither is forced to be true.

Result: Neither conclusion follows from the given statements.

Explore the full course: Tcs Live Preparation

Loading lesson…