Statements: Some kings are queens. All queens are beautiful. Conclusions: All…
2024
Statements:
Some kings are queens.
All queens are beautiful.
Conclusions:
All kings are beautiful.
All queens are kings.
- A.
Only conclusion I follows
- B.
Only conclusion II follows
- C.
Either I or II follows
- D.
Neither I nor II follows
Attempted by 44 students.
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: D
Concept: In syllogisms, if either premise is particular (an "I" or "O" statement, e.g. "Some X are Y") rather than universal, any conclusion that validly follows must also be particular — a universal conclusion can never be drawn from a pair containing a particular premise. Also, a particular statement such as "Some X are Y" converts only to "Some Y are X", never to the universal "All Y are X" (that reversal is an illicit conversion).
Application:
"Some kings are queens" is particular (an I-type statement, since it says only 'some').
"All queens are beautiful" is universal (an A-type statement).
Because one premise is particular, only a particular conclusion could ever be validly drawn from this pair — combining them through the shared middle term 'queens' would give something like "Some kings are beautiful", a particular claim. Neither conclusion offered here is that.
Conclusion I, "All kings are beautiful", is universal, so it can never validly follow when one of the two premises is particular — it fails on form alone.
Conclusion II, "All queens are kings", tries to reverse "Some kings are queens" into a universal claim about every queen; a particular premise reverses only to another particular statement ("Some queens are kings"), never to a universal one, so this is also invalid.
Cross-check: Let kings = {A, B, C} and queens = {B, D}, with B the one king who is also a queen (this satisfies "some kings are queens"). Let B and D (every queen) be beautiful, satisfying the second premise. Now let A and C (kings who are not queens) not be beautiful — "all kings are beautiful" is false. And D is a queen who is not a king — "all queens are kings" is false too. This single model satisfies both premises while making both conclusions false, so neither is forced to be true.
Result: Neither conclusion follows from the given statements.