Select the code which is not correct about Venn diagram :

2016

Select the code which is not correct about Venn diagram :

  1. A.

    Venn diagram represents propositions as well as classes.

  2. B.

    It can provide clear method of notation.

  3. C.

    It can be either valid or invalid.

  4. D.

    It can provide the direct method of testing the validity.

Attempted by 1 students.

Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: C

A Venn diagram is a notational device used in categorical logic: circles represent classes, and shading or marking a region represents a categorical proposition (that a class is empty, or that it has at least one member). Crucially, validity and invalidity are properties of an argument (a syllogism) — they describe whether a conclusion is logically forced by its premises. They are not properties of the diagram itself, which is simply drawn correctly or incorrectly when representing that argument.

Applying this to the four statements: the claim that a Venn diagram represents both classes and propositions holds, the claim that it provides a clear method of notation holds, and the claim that it provides a direct method of testing validity holds too, since inspecting a fully-drawn diagram is exactly the direct way logicians test whether a syllogism's conclusion follows. The statement that a Venn diagram 'can be either valid or invalid' does not fit this picture: validity/invalidity belongs to the syllogism being tested, not to the diagram used to test it.

  • Represents propositions as well as classes — true; circles show classes, shading/marking shows propositions.

  • Provides a clear method of notation — true; that is the diagram's basic purpose.

  • Provides a direct method of testing validity — true; reading the completed diagram directly shows whether the argument holds.

  • Can be either valid or invalid — this is the mismatch: 'valid/invalid' describes the syllogism being tested, not the diagram itself, so this statement is not correct about a Venn diagram.

Because the statements about representing classes and propositions, about providing a method of notation, and about providing a direct test of validity are all true, the statement that a Venn diagram 'can be either valid or invalid' is the one that is not correct about Venn diagrams.

Explore the full course: Ssc Cgl Tier 1

Loading lesson…