Which one of the following statements is true?
2023
Which one of the following statements is true?
- A.
Children are capable of learning two or more languages at a time
- B.
Home language of students can seriously interfere with their formal learning and therefore should not be made medium of instruction
- C.
Implementing three-language formula may create more complex difficulties in the system
- D.
Multilingualism cannot be used as a resource in India
Attempted by 44 students.
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: A
Correct statement: Children are capable of learning two or more languages at a time. Research on language acquisition shows that young children can acquire multiple languages simultaneously without long-term harm to language development.
Simultaneous exposure leads to natural bilingual or multilingual development when each language has sufficient input.
Multilingualism often brings cognitive benefits such as improved metalinguistic awareness and executive control.
Children do not necessarily get confused if languages are used consistently in different contexts and there is adequate exposure to each language.
Why the other statements are not correct or need nuance:
The claim that the home language should not be the medium of instruction is mistaken because the home language often supports conceptual understanding and learning. Using it as a medium or scaffold can improve comprehension and reduce dropouts.
The idea that a three-language formula will necessarily create more complex difficulties is an oversimplification. Implementation challenges exist, but with proper planning, materials, and teacher training the approach can be effective and beneficial.
Stating that multilingualism cannot be used as a resource in India is incorrect. India's linguistic diversity can be leveraged pedagogically to improve learning and maintain cultural identity.
Classroom implications:
Use the home language to scaffold new concepts and gradually build academic language in additional languages.
Design multilingual policies with attention to resources, teacher preparation, and consistent exposure to each language.
Encourage translanguaging and positive attitudes toward students' languages to make instruction inclusive and effective.