'Spare the rod and spoil the child' - this assumption is related to the type…
2014
'Spare the rod and spoil the child' - this assumption is related to the type of discipline which has been advocated
- A.
By naturalist philosophy
- B.
In Victorian Era
- C.
By pragmatist philosophy
- D.
In Democratic Era
Attempted by 178 students.
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: B
Concept. A maxim or pedagogical assumption is placed with the social and educational outlook whose attitude toward discipline it expresses. To locate a saying, ask which view treats discipline the way the saying does - permissive and growth-following, experience-based and child-centred, rights-respecting and participatory, or strict, obedience-first and accepting of physical punishment.
Application. The proverb "Spare the rod and spoil the child" treats the rod - physical punishment - as necessary to raise a well-behaved child. This makes obedience and moral correction the goal and accepts corporal punishment as the means. That outlook on family and school discipline is exactly what is associated with the Victorian Era, when caning and other corporal punishment were a routine, accepted part of bringing up and schooling children.
Contrast - how the other outlooks treat discipline:
Naturalist philosophy: follows the child's natural development and opposes harsh, coercive punishment, so it cannot be the home of a use-the-rod maxim.
Pragmatist philosophy: builds learning on experience and problem-solving in child-centred, democratic classrooms rather than through physical punishment.
Democratic Era and approaches: prioritise children's rights, autonomy and participation - methods that directly conflict with a punishment-first proverb.
Result. Of the four, only the Victorian Era frames discipline as strict, obedience-driven and accepting of corporal punishment, which is what the proverb assumes.