Which of the following compounds is most reactive toward a nucleophilic…
2019
Which of the following compounds is most reactive toward a nucleophilic addition reaction?
- A.
NO2–C6H4–CHO
- B.
C6H5–CHO
- C.
CH3–C6H4–CHO
- D.
CH3O–C6H4–CHO
Attempted by 2 students.
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: A
Concept
In a nucleophilic addition to a carbonyl compound, the nucleophile attacks the electrophilic carbonyl carbon. Greater electron deficiency at that carbon generally increases the reaction rate.
When condensed aryl-aldehyde formulas omit locants, the standard comparison treats ring positions and steric conditions as comparable and ranks the compounds by the substituents’ dominant electronic effects.
Application
The nitro group has a strong –I effect at every ring position; at positions conjugated with the aldehyde group, it also withdraws by resonance. Under the comparable-position convention, NO2–C6H4–CHO therefore has the greatest carbonyl electron deficiency in this set.
Contrast
C6H5–CHO has no additional ring substituent, so it represents the baseline reactivity of benzaldehyde.
The methyl group (–CH3) donates electron density through its +I effect and hyperconjugation, reducing carbonyl electrophilicity.
The methoxy substituent donates by resonance at conjugating ring positions; at a meta position only its much weaker –I effect operates. It does not produce exceptional carbonyl electron deficiency in this standard substituent comparison.
Cross-check
Across standard ring-substituent comparisons, nitro is markedly more electron-withdrawing than hydrogen, methyl, or methoxy. Thus NO2–C6H4–CHO is the most reactive compound toward nucleophilic addition in this set.