At the primary school stage, most of the teachers should be women because they

2013

At the primary school stage, most of the teachers should be women because they

Answer: D. can deal with children with love and affection.Concept: A teacher's suitability for a particular stage of schooling is judged by the developmental needs of the learners at that stage. In the primary years…

  1. A.

    can teach children better than men.

  2. B.

    know basic content better than men.

  3. C.

    are available on lower salaries.

  4. D.

    can deal with children with love and affection.

Attempted by 9 students.

Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: D

Concept: A teacher's suitability for a particular stage of schooling is judged by the developmental needs of the learners at that stage. In the primary years (roughly ages 6 to 11) the child is still building attachment and emotional security, and that security is the pre-condition on which early learning rests. At this stage the teacher's affective role — warmth, patience, care — carries more pedagogical weight than advanced subject mastery, while cost of employment and blanket claims about ability are not educational grounds at all.

Application: The stem asks for the educationally defensible reason for preferring women teachers at the primary stage. Applying the principle, the acceptable ground is the affective one: that such teachers can deal with children with love and affection, which meets the young child's need for emotional security and makes the classroom a safe place to learn in.

Cross-check — why the other grounds do not hold:

  • "can teach children better than men" — a blanket claim of superior instructional ability tied to gender. Teaching competence is produced by teacher education, training and reflective practice, so it cannot be asserted of one sex as a class.

  • "know basic content better than men" — primary-level content is common to every trained teacher and is covered by the same teacher-education curriculum; mastery of it is not gender-linked.

  • "are available on lower salaries" — an administrative cost argument. It violates the principle of equal pay for equal work and says nothing about what the child needs in order to learn.

Result: the sustainable reason is the affective one — women teachers are preferred at the primary stage because they can deal with children with love and affection. Note that this states a developmental need of the young child; it is not a claim that men are incapable of affection or of teaching young children well.

Explore the full course: Nta Ugc Net Paper 1

Loading lesson…