Given below is a statement followed by two courses of action I and II. Assume…
2023
Given below is a statement followed by two courses of action I and II.
Assume the statement to be true and decide which of the suggested courses of action should follow.
Statement: One of the students in school is behaving very rudely with other students, even physically hurting them.
Courses of action: I. Student should be expelled from the school.
II. Counsellor in school can have sessions with that student to understand and change his behaviour.
- A.
If course of action I is to be followed
- B.
If course of action II is to be followed
- C.
If I and II both courses of action are to be followed
- D.
If none of the courses of action is to be followed
- E.
Question not attempted
Attempted by 21 students.
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: B
To determine the most appropriate course of action, we must evaluate the situation's severity and the goal of school discipline: safety and rehabilitation.
Analysis of Courses of Action
Course of Action I: Expelling the student.
Expulsion is a drastic measure. While it immediately removes the threat to other students, it does not address the root cause of the student's behavior and deprives them of their right to education. It is generally considered a last resort after other interventions have failed.
Course of Action II: Counselling sessions.
This is a constructive and rehabilitative approach. By engaging a school counsellor, the school can identify the underlying issues—such as personal, emotional, or social stressors—that may be causing the aggressive behavior. This provides the student with an opportunity to understand the impact of their actions, learn coping mechanisms, and modify their behavior while remaining in an educational environment.
Given that schools have a duty of care to all students, a balanced approach is best. Counselling directly targets the behavior, making it the most logical and ethical first step. Therefore, Course of Action II is the recommended path.