“If X, then Y unless Z” is represented by which of the following formulae in…
2017
“If X, then Y unless Z” is represented by which of the following formulae in propositional logic ?
- A.
(X ∧ Y) → ¬ Z
- B.
(X ∧ ¬ Z) → Y
- C.
X → (Y ∧ ¬ Z)
- D.
Y → (X ∧ ¬ Z)
Attempted by 191 students.
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: B
Answer: (X ∧ ¬Z) → Y
Explanation: 'If X, then Y unless Z' means that when X holds and Z does not hold, Y must hold. The phrase 'Y unless Z' is equivalent to 'if not Z then Y' (¬Z → Y).
Rewrite 'Y unless Z' as an implication: ¬Z → Y.
The whole sentence becomes: X → (¬Z → Y).
Use the equivalence between nested implications and a conjunction: X → (¬Z → Y) is equivalent to (X ∧ ¬Z) → Y.
Brief notes on the other formulas:
(X ∧ Y) → ¬Z: This says X and Y together force ¬Z, which is unrelated to the intended conditional about Y unless Z.
X → (Y ∧ ¬Z): This requires ¬Z whenever X holds, which is stronger than 'unless' and thus incorrect.
Y → (X ∧ ¬Z): This reverses the implication direction; it constrains X and Z based on Y, not Y based on X and Z.
A video solution is available for this question — log in and enroll to watch it.