Statements: The national norm is 100 beds per thousand populations but in this…
2023
Statements:
The national norm is 100 beds per thousand populations but in this state, 150 beds per thousand are available in the hospitals.
Conclusions:
(I) Our national norm is appropriate.
(II) The state's health system is taking adequate care in this regard.
- A.
Only conclusion I follows
- B.
Only conclusion II follows
- C.
Either I or II follows
- D.
Neither I nor II follows
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: B
Concept
In statement-and-conclusion reasoning, a conclusion 'follows' only if it is a certain, direct inference from the statement alone. A conclusion built on an outside value judgement, an assumption, or information the statement never gives does not follow — however reasonable it may sound.
Application
The statement gives two figures: the national norm is 100 beds per thousand population, while this state actually provides 150 beds per thousand — 50 more than the norm.
Conclusion I ('the norm is appropriate') requires judging whether 100 is the right benchmark. The statement only reports the figure; it supplies no basis for judging its fairness. So Conclusion I brings in an assumption the statement never makes and does not follow.
Conclusion II ('adequate care') is confirmed directly: 150 against a norm of 100 is a clear numeric excess, and providing more capacity than the benchmark requires is exactly what 'taking adequate care' means. So Conclusion II follows.
Cross-check
The 'either/or' pattern applies only when two conclusions are complementary alternatives about the same single fact. Here, Conclusion I concerns whether the benchmark itself is fair while Conclusion II concerns the state's actual performance against that benchmark — two separate matters, not a complementary pair — so treating them as 'either/or,' or dismissing both as 'neither,' does not fit the statement.
Therefore, only Conclusion II follows — matching the saved answer.