Directions: Read the passage given below and then answer the question that…
2025
Directions: Read the passage given below and then answer the question that follows it. Choose the most appropriate answer.
Ask an American schoolchild what he or she is learning in school these days and you might even get a reply, provided you ask it in Spanish. But don’t bother, here’s the answer: Americans nowadays are not learning any of the things that we learned in our day, like reading and writing. Apparently, these are considered fusty old subjects, invented by white males to oppress women and minorities.
What are they learning? In a Vermont college town, I found the answer sitting in a toy store book rack, next to typical kids’ books like ‘Heather Has Two Mommies’ and ‘Daddy Is Dysfunctional’. It’s a teacher’s guide called ‘Happy To Be Me’, subtitled ‘Building Self-Esteem’.
Self-esteem, as it turns out, is a big subject in American classrooms. Many American schools see building it as important as teaching reading and writing. They call it “whole language” teaching, borrowing terminology from the granola people to compete in the education marketplace.
No one ever spent a moment building my self-esteem when I was in school. In fact, from the day I first stepped inside a classroom, my self-esteem was one big demolition site. All that mattered was “the subject,” be it geography, history, or mathematics. I was praised when I remembered that “near”, “fit”, “friendly”, “pleasing”, “like” and their opposites took the dative case in Latin. I was reviled when I forgot what a cosine was good for. Generally, I lived my school years beneath a torrent of castigation so consistent I eventually ceased to hear it, as people who live near the sea eventually stop hearing the waves.
Schools have changed. Reviling is out, for one thing. More important, subjects have changed. Whereas I learned English, modern kids learn something called “language skills.” Whereas I learned writing, modern kids learn something called “communication”. Communication, the book tells us, is seven percent words, 23 percent facial expression, 20 percent tone of voice, and 50 percent body language. So this column, with its carefully chosen words, would earn me at most a grade of seven percent. That is if the school even gave out something as oppressive and demanding as grades.
The result is that, in place of English classes, American children are getting a course in How to ‘Win Friends and Influence People’. Consider the new attitude toward journal writing: I remember one high school English class when we were required to keep a journal. The idea was to emulate those great writers who confided in diaries, searching their souls and honing their critical thinking on paper.
‘Happy To Be Me’ states that journals are a great way for students to get in touch with their feelings. Tell students they can write one sentence or a whole page. Reassure them that no one, not even you, will read what they write. After the unit, hopefully, all students will be feeling good about themselves and will want to share some of their entries with the class.
There was a time when no self-respecting book for English teachers would use “great” or “hopefully” that way. Moreover, back then, the purpose of English courses (an antique term for “Unit”) was not to help students “feel good about themselves.” Which is good, because all that reviling didn’t make me feel particularly good about anything.
Question: According to the passage, the author’s intention is to get us to:
Answer: D. rethink educational strategies. — Concept: A question about an author’s intention asks for the goal of the passage as a whole, not the topic of any single paragraph. Two tests settle it. The…
- A.
confirm current trends.
- B.
reassure parents.
- C.
think about what constitutes communication.
- D.
rethink educational strategies.
Attempted by 35 students.
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: D
Concept: A question about an author’s intention asks for the goal of the passage as a whole, not the topic of any single paragraph. Two tests settle it. The attitude test: the stated purpose must agree with the evaluative stance the writing itself takes. The scope test: the stated purpose must account for every stretch of the passage, not for one illustration inside it. A choice can be true of a few lines and still fail as a statement of intention.
Application:
Read the stance. Traditional subjects are labelled “fusty old subjects”; the borrowed label “whole language” is traced to “the granola people”; grades are called “oppressive and demanding”; and a column of carefully chosen words is said to earn “at most a grade of seven percent”. The register used for present-day practice is consistently derisive, while the older subject-based schooling is treated wryly but seriously — “All that mattered was ‘the subject’”.
Read the scope. Each section pairs an older practice with a newer one: English against “language skills”; writing against “communication”; journals kept to hone critical thinking against journals kept to “get in touch with their feelings”; mastery of a subject against “building self-esteem”. The pairing runs from the opening paragraph to the closing sentence.
Combine the two readings. A derisive stance towards present practice, sustained across what schools teach, how they teach it and what the courses are ultimately for, is aimed at making the reader reconsider the strategy behind schooling — not at settling any one of the illustrations used along the way.
Cross-check against the other choices, by value:
“confirm current trends” fails the attitude test: the words the passage itself chooses for present-day practice are mocking, so endorsement of that practice cannot be its goal.
“reassure parents” fails both tests: no parent is addressed anywhere in the passage, and its closing line — “all that reviling didn’t make me feel particularly good about anything” — is self-mocking rather than consoling.
“think about what constitutes communication” fails the scope test: the “seven percent words … 50 percent body language” breakdown is one illustration standing beside self-esteem units, “language skills” and journal writing, and a whole-passage intention has to cover all of them.
“rethink educational strategies” satisfies both tests: it matches the critical stance and it covers every section of the passage.
Result: The author’s intention is to get us to rethink educational strategies.