Let 𝐴 be any 𝑛 Γ— π‘š matrix, where π‘š > 𝑛. Which of the following statements…

2024

Let 𝐴 be any 𝑛 Γ— π‘š matrix, where π‘š > 𝑛. Which of the following statements is/are TRUE about the system of linear equations 𝐴π‘₯ = 0 ?

  1. A.

    There exist at least π‘š βˆ’ 𝑛 linearly independent solutions to this system

  2. B.

    There exist π‘š βˆ’ 𝑛 linearly independent vectors such that every solution is a linear combination of these vectors

  3. C.

    There exists a non-zero solution in which at least π‘š βˆ’ 𝑛 variables are 0

  4. D.

    There exists a solution in which at least 𝑛 variables are non-zero

Attempted by 99 students.

Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: A

Key idea: Use the rank-nullity theorem.

By the rank-nullity theorem, rank(A) + nullity(A) = m. Since rank(A) ≀ n, we have nullity(A) = m βˆ’ rank(A) β‰₯ m βˆ’ n. The nullspace therefore has dimension at least m βˆ’ n, so there exist at least m βˆ’ n linearly independent solutions to A x = 0.

  • Statement that there exist at least m βˆ’ n linearly independent solutions: true. Reason: nullity(A) β‰₯ m βˆ’ n, so any basis of the nullspace provides at least m βˆ’ n independent solutions.

  • Statement that there exist m βˆ’ n linearly independent vectors that span all solutions: false in general. Reason: nullity may be larger than m βˆ’ n, so you would need more than m βˆ’ n vectors to span the nullspace. Example: if A is the zero matrix then nullspace = R^m has dimension m, which can exceed m βˆ’ n.

  • Statement that there exists a non-zero solution with at least m βˆ’ n variables equal to zero: false in general. Counterexample: let n = 2, m = 3 and A = [[1,0,1],[0,1,1]]. Solutions are scalar multiples of (βˆ’1,βˆ’1,1), which has no zero entries, so there is no nonzero solution with at least m βˆ’ n = 1 zero.

  • Statement that there exists a solution with at least n non-zero variables: false in general. Counterexample: choose A = [I_n | 0_{nΓ—(mβˆ’n)}]. Then every solution has first n entries zero and at most m βˆ’ n nonzeros. If m βˆ’ n < n (for example m = n + 1), no solution can have n nonzeros.

Conclusion: Only the first statement is guaranteed to be true for every n Γ— m matrix with m > n.

A video solution is available for this question β€” log in and enroll to watch it.

Explore the full course: Gate Guidance By Sanchit Sir