Which logic is designed to address the problem of referential
2026
Which logic is designed to address the problem of referential opacity in propositional attitudes?
Regular Logic
Modal Logic
First-order logic
Predicate logic
- A.
1
- B.
2
- C.
3
- D.
4
Attempted by 54 students.
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: B
Referential opacity occurs in statements involving propositional attitudes like belief, knowledge, necessity, etc., where substitution of identical terms may change truth.
Example:
“John believes that Superman can fly”
Even though Superman = Clark Kent,
“John believes that Clark Kent can fly” may not be true.
Why Classical Logic Fails
First-order / Predicate logic follows substitution of equals.
But in such contexts, substitution fails ⇒ cannot handle referential opacity.
Why Modal Logic WorksModal logic introduces operators like:
□ (necessarily)
◇ (possibly)
Belief/knowledge operators
These create intensional contexts, where meaning depends on more than truth value.
Hence, it correctly models propositional attitudes.