Event A: Curfew has been declared in the city. Event B: There is hardly any…

2024

Event A: Curfew has been declared in the city.

Event B: There is hardly any visible activity in the city and the shops are closed.

  1. A.

    If ‘A’ is the immediate and principal cause and 'B’ is its effect.

  2. B.

    If 'B' is an effect but ‘A’ is not its immediate and principal cause.

  3. C.

    If ‘A’ is the effect and 'B' is its immediate and principal cause.

  4. D.

    If ‘A’ is an effect but 'B’ is not its immediate and principal cause.

Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: A

Concept: In cause-and-effect reasoning, the immediate and principal cause is the event that occurs first and directly, necessarily produces the other event, with no independent factor needed in between; the effect could not occur in that way without the cause.

Application: Event A — the declaration of a curfew — is an administrative order issued first. Event B — the near-total absence of visible activity and the closing of shops — follows directly and necessarily from that order, since a curfew explicitly restricts people from stepping outdoors and businesses from operating. No intervening cause is required to connect the two: once the curfew takes effect, the conditions described in B follow immediately.

Cross-check — why the other readings fail:

  • Reversing the direction (treating low street activity as producing the curfew) does not hold: a curfew is an administrative order issued by authorities, and public inactivity is not a cause of that order.

  • Reading B as an effect but denying A as its immediate cause fails because no independent, intervening factor is needed — the curfew alone directly explains the described conditions.

  • Reading A as an effect misreads its role: the curfew is the originating action here, not a consequence of anything stated in the two events.

Result: the curfew (A) is the immediate and principal cause, and the absence of visible activity (B) is its direct effect.

Explore the full course: Deloitte Nla