This year, on which day does Rishi's birthday fall? Statements I. His birthday…
2023
This year, on which day does Rishi's birthday fall?
Statements
I. His birthday falls strictly between June 27 and June 30 (excluding these two dates), June 27 being Tuesday.
II. His birthday is not on Thursday.
- A.
Statement 2 alone is sufficient
- B.
Statement 1 alone is sufficient
- C.
Both Statements put together are sufficient
- D.
Both Statements even put together are not sufficient
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: C
Concept: In Data Sufficiency questions, judge each statement's power to fix a single, unique answer on its own first; only when neither statement alone succeeds do you check whether combining them removes every remaining ambiguity. A calendar clue that names a date range together with one date's weekday fixes the weekday of every date in that stretch; a clue that only excludes one weekday out of seven, with no date-range information of its own, cannot by itself identify which specific date the birthday falls on.
Statement I fixes June 27 as a Tuesday and places the birthday strictly inside the window running from June 27 to June 30 — that leaves June 28 (Wednesday) and June 29 (Thursday) as the two dates consistent with it, so Statement I alone cannot choose between them.
Statement II states only that the birthday is not on a Thursday — this excludes just one weekday out of seven, and with no month or date-range attached, it cannot by itself identify any specific date, so Statement II alone is nowhere near sufficient.
Combining them: apply Statement II's day-of-week exclusion to the two dates that Statement I already isolated. June 29 falls on Thursday, so it is ruled out; June 28 falls on Wednesday, so it survives and is the only date left.
Cross-check: Checking the surviving date against both clues confirms it: it sits inside the June 27–30 window implied by Statement I, and its weekday is not Thursday, so it satisfies Statement II as well — no other date inside that window does.
Neither statement decides the birthday alone, but together they leave exactly one date standing, so both statements put together are sufficient.