Which of the following statements is incorrect in the historical…

2019

Which of the following statements is incorrect in the historical reconstruction of tribal people?

  1. A.

    Contemporary historians and travellers give scanty information about tribes.

  2. B.

    Most tribal groups kept written records.

  3. C.

    Tribal people preserved rich customs and oral traditions.

  4. D.

    Tribal societies depended on each other for their diverse needs.

Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: B

Concept: Most tribal communities across India did not maintain written records of their own; instead, their history and identity were carried forward mainly through oral tradition, songs, and everyday customs. As a result, historians reconstructing tribal history depend heavily on scattered contemporary accounts (administrators, missionaries, travellers) and the tribes' own oral heritage, rather than on documents authored by the tribal communities themselves.

Application: Checking each statement against this idea:

  • Historians giving only scattered, sparse information about tribal groups is true, since few outsiders wrote about them and their accounts are incidental.

  • Most tribal groups keeping written records of their own is false; the overwhelming historical pattern across Indian tribal societies was oral transmission of history, not internally maintained written documentation, which is exactly why this claim runs counter to the historical record.

  • Tribal communities preserving rich customs and oral traditions is true; oral tradition was the primary vehicle for transmitting tribal history and identity.

  • Tribal societies depending on one another for their diverse needs is true; jhum cultivators, hunter-gatherers, herders, and settled agriculturists exchanged goods and services as part of everyday tribal economic life.

Cross-check: If tribal communities had, in fact, kept extensive written records of their own, historians would not need to lean so heavily on scattered outsider accounts and inherited oral tradition; the very reliance described above would not make sense. This internal contradiction confirms that the claim about written record-keeping is the one at odds with the historical record, making it the incorrect statement.

Explore the full course: Ctet Paper 2

Loading lesson…