Which one of the following is not used for calculating the age of the Earth?
2013
Which one of the following is not used for calculating the age of the Earth?
- A.
Tidal force of the Moon
- B.
Salinity in the Oceans
- C.
Attractional force of the Earth
- D.
Rate of Sedimentation
Attempted by 3 students.
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: C
Concept
A phenomenon can be used to calculate the age of the Earth only if it involves a quantity that accumulates measurably at a known (or estimable) rate over time, so that elapsed time can be recovered as accumulated quantity divided by rate. A body’s gravitational (attractional) force, by contrast, is a static physical property fixed by its present mass and the distance to the object being attracted; it does not accumulate or change systematically with the passage of geological time, so it carries no time signature and cannot be used to date anything.
Application
Historically, geologists and physicists used several rate-based, cumulative processes to estimate Earth’s age:
Tidal friction: the Moon’s tidal pull on Earth’s oceans dissipates rotational energy, very gradually lengthening the day; this measurable rate of slowing was used (notably by Lord Kelvin and later G. H. Darwin) to bound Earth’s age.
Ocean salinity: rivers carry dissolved salts into the sea at an estimable annual rate; dividing the ocean’s total salt content by that rate gave an early (if rough) age estimate, an approach proposed by Edmond Halley and later applied by John Joly.
Rate of sedimentation: dividing the total thickness of a sedimentary rock sequence by an estimated deposition rate gave 19th-century geologists a rough calculation of the time represented by the strata.
Earth’s attractional (gravitational) force depends only on its present mass and radius. It does not grow, shrink, or accumulate with time, so there is no accumulated quantity that could be divided by a rate to yield an elapsed-time value — it cannot yield a time estimate at all. That is why “Attractional force of the Earth” is the one option that was never used as an age-dating method, making it the correct answer.
Cross-check
Modern radiometric dating measures the ratio of a radioactive parent isotope to its stable decay product in a rock or mineral sample; because radioactive decay follows a fixed exponential law with a known decay constant, that ratio converts directly into an elapsed-time value, placing Earth’s age at about 4.54 billion years. This is the same rate-based logic, in a far more rigorous form, that made tidal friction, salinity, and sedimentation plausible (if imprecise) 19th-century proxies. Gravitational attraction plays no role in any age-dating technique, old or modern, confirming that it is the correct exception among the four options.