Directions : In each of the following questions a statement is given, followed…
2025
Directions : In each of the following questions a statement is given, followed by two conclusions. Give answer :
Statement : A medical College has started a cell which will conduct counseling workshops in the field of stress management to patients and general public.
Conclusion :
I. The hospital has needed resources to start such activity.
II. Patients and general public feel a need to have such cell in the hospital.
- A.
Only conclusion I follows.
- B.
Only conclusion II follows.
- C.
Either I or II follows.
- D.
Both I and II follow.
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: D
Rule for action-based Statement-and-Conclusion items: when a statement reports that an organisation has ALREADY undertaken an activity aimed at a specific audience, two things are treated as necessarily implied by that single fact (unless the statement itself rules them out): (a) the organisation had the resources needed to undertake it, and (b) the activity addresses a real, felt need of the intended audience -- organisations do not commit resources to activities without a reason to.
Conclusion I -- resource availability: the statement states as fact that the medical college HAS STARTED the counseling cell -- a completed action, not a mere proposal. Setting up and running such a cell requires infrastructure, trained counsellors and funding; since the college has already taken this step, it must have had these resources in place. Conclusion I follows.
Conclusion II -- felt need: the cell is aimed specifically at patients and the general public, not set up in the abstract. Under the same convention, a targeted service is created because the target group's need for it is recognised. Conclusion II follows.
"Only conclusion I follows." -- Accepting the resource-related inference while rejecting the audience-related inference applies two different evidentiary standards to the same statement, without stating why one inference deserves more weight than the other. Go back and check whether the statement gives any actual basis for treating them unequally before settling on this reading.
"Only conclusion II follows." -- Accepting the audience-related inference while rejecting the resource-related inference applies two different evidentiary standards to the same statement, without stating why one inference deserves more weight than the other. Go back and check whether the statement gives any actual basis for treating them unequally before settling on this reading.
"Either I or II follows." -- This assumes that accepting one of the two inferences requires rejecting the other. Re-examine the statement for any element that would make the resource-related and audience-related inferences genuinely incompatible with each other before applying an either-or framing to them.
Cross-check by testing each partial reading: accepting only resource-availability (Conclusion I alone) would mean the college built a service nobody needed, which contradicts the same convention; accepting only felt-need (Conclusion II alone) would mean the college attempted this without adequate means, contradicting the fact that it has already started. Neither can be dropped without contradiction, so both conclusions hold together -- confirmed against the standard answer key for this item.