What is the area of the piece of glass? Statements: I. The glass is…
2024
What is the area of the piece of glass? Statements: I. The glass is rectangular in shape. II. The base of the glass is 25 cm.
- A.
Statement I alone is sufficient.
- B.
Statement II alone is sufficient.
- C.
Both the statements when put together are sufficient.
- D.
Both the statements put together are not sufficient.
Attempted by 1 students.
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: D
Concept
In a data-sufficiency problem you do not compute a final number; you only decide whether the information given is enough to pin down a unique answer. A statement (or combination) is "sufficient" only if it forces exactly one possible value of the quantity asked. The area of a rectangle is length × breadth, so to fix the area you must know BOTH of its two perpendicular dimensions.
Application
The quantity asked is the area of the glass, which needs two dimensions (a base and a height).
"The glass is rectangular in shape" fixes the formula to use (length × breadth) but gives no measurement at all, so it cannot produce a number on its own.
"The base of the glass is 25 cm" supplies only one dimension. Even assuming a rectangle, the height is still unknown, so the area is not fixed on its own.
Taking both together, we know the shape is a rectangle and one side is 25 cm, but the second dimension (height) is still missing. Area = 25 × height stays undetermined because height can be any positive value.
Cross-check
A 25 cm × 10 cm glass gives 250 cm², while a 25 cm × 20 cm glass gives 500 cm². Both fit every piece of information given, yet the areas differ — so even with both statements the area is not uniquely determined.
Hence even both statements together are not sufficient to find the area.