It is a cold night in December and in a remote village, an old storyteller is…

2023

It is a cold night in December and in a remote village, an old storyteller is sitting by the hearth-fire with a group of students who have come home for the winter holidays. They love visiting her to listen to her stories, but tonight Granny is not her usual chirpy self; she looks much older and seems to be agitated over something. One of the boys asks her whether she is not feeling well and tells her that if so, they can come back another night. But instead of answering the question, the old woman starts talking and tells them that on a certain night a peculiar wind blows through the village, which seems to start from the region of the graveyard and which sounds like a hymn. She also tells them that tonight is that kind of a night. At first the youngsters are skeptical and tell her that they cannot hear anything and that such things are not possible, but the old woman rebukes them by saying that they are not paying attention to what is happening around them. She tells them that youngsters of today have forgotten how to listen to the voice of the earth and the wind. They feel chastised and make a show of straining their ears to listen more attentively and to their utter surprise, they hear the beginning of a low hum in the distance. They listen for some time and tell her, almost in triumph, that they can hear only an eerie sound. ‘No’, the storyteller almost shouts, ‘Listen carefully. Tonight is the anniversary of that dreadful Sunday.’ There is a death-like silence in the room and some of them begin to look uneasy because they too had heard vague rumours of army atrocities that took place in the village on a Sunday long before they were born. Storyteller and audience strain to listen more attentively and suddenly a strange thing happens : as the wind whirls past the house, it increases in volume and for the briefest of moments, seems to hover above the house. Then it resumes its whirling as though hurrying away to other regions beyond human habitation. The young people are stunned because they hear the new element in the volume and a certain uncanny lilt lingers on in the wake of its departure. The old woman jumps up from her seat and looking at each one in turn asks, ‘You heard it, didn’t you? Didn’t I tell you? It was Apenyo’s last song’ and she hums a tune softly, almost to herself. The youngsters cannot deny that they heard the note but are puzzled because they do not know what she is talking about. As the old woman stands apart humming the tune, they look at her with wonder. There is a peculiar glow on her face and she seems to have changed into a new self, more alive and animated than earlier. After a while a young girl timidly approaches her and asks, ‘Grandmother, what are you talking about? Whose last song?’

The old storyteller whips around and surveys the group as though seeing them for the first time. She then heaves a deep sigh and with infinite sadness in her voice, spreads her arms wide and whispers, ‘You have not heard about that song? You do not know about Apenyo? Then come and listen carefully ...’

Thus, on a cold December night in a remote village, an old storyteller gathers the young of the land around the leaping flames of a hearth and squats on the bare earth among them to pass on the story of that Black Sunday when a young and beautiful singer sang her last song even as one more Naga village began weeping for her ravaged and ruined children.

[An extract from ‘The Last Song’ in These Hills Called Home, by Temsula Ao, Penguin Books, New Delhi : 2006, p.31–33]

What was so special about ‘that night’?

Answer: B. It was that fateful night when a peculiar wind blewConceptIn literal reading comprehension, a quoted expression is resolved by following the surrounding chain of actions, repeated ideas, and cause-and-effect…

  1. A.

    It was a stormy night with incessant thunder and rain

  2. B.

    It was that fateful night when a peculiar wind blew

  3. C.

    It was a silent night when the moon had a lurid glow

  4. D.

    More than one of the above

  5. E.

    None of the above

Attempted by 1 students.

Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: B

Concept

In literal reading comprehension, a quoted expression is resolved by following the surrounding chain of actions, repeated ideas, and cause-and-effect links. The supported interpretation must account for the full context, while vivid details introduced only by an answer choice cannot establish the referent.

Application

The storyteller says that such a peculiar wind blows on a certain kind of night and that this night is the anniversary of the dreadful Sunday. The wind then whirls past the house, grows in volume, seems briefly to hover, and carries the uncanny note identified as Apenyo’s last song. Together, these connected details make the night fateful and distinguish it by the peculiar wind.

Contrast

  • The storm description adds incessant thunder and rain, although the extract attributes the growing eerie sound to the wind.

  • The silent-night description moves the peculiar glow to the moon, although the extract places that glow on the storyteller’s face.

  • Only the fateful-wind description follows the complete evidence chain, so neither set-based response applies.

Cross-check

The closing sentence identifies the remembered event as Black Sunday, when Apenyo sang her last song and the Naga village suffered. This confirms why the night is fateful, while the earlier wind episode explains the specific sign by which it is recognized.

Result

Thus, the supported answer is: It was that fateful night when a peculiar wind blew.

Explore the full course: Bpsc

Loading lesson…