"I'm home!" Earl shouted as he walked in the door. His wife Gail came bounding…
2024
"I'm home!" Earl shouted as he walked in the door. His wife Gail came bounding down the stairs. She hadn't seen him since he had left to go on his silly fishing trip two weeks ago. "I missed you, Husband. Did you catch anything?" Gail reluctantly asked, knowing that Earl was not a very good fisherman. Earl scratched his head and responded, "You're not going to believe what I'm bringing home." Earl unzipped a cooler and pulled out several perfectly filleted salmon steaks. "Wow, Earl, I didn't know that you could fillet a fish like that." Earl looked around the room a little bit and scratched his head, "Uh, yeah, Jeff taught me how." Gail looked at him suspiciously. "Well, let me help you unpack." As Gail was helping Earl unpack his truck, she found a receipt from the grocery store. It was dated from that morning. What she saw was both disappointing and unsurprising.
Earl scratched his head and responded why?
- A.
Earl was lying to Gail
- B.
Earl wanted to proof he was good fisherman
- C.
Gail was lying to Earl
- D.
None of These
Attempted by 3 students.
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: A
Answer: Earl was lying to Gail.
Why: The passage provides concrete evidence that contradicts Earl's claim.
A grocery receipt dated that morning was found, indicating the salmon were purchased rather than caught.
Earl's comment that someone taught him how to fillet the fish is a suspicious detail that could be a cover story.
Taken together, these facts show Earl misrepresented where the fish came from.
Conclusion: The best-supported conclusion is that Earl lied to Gail about catching the salmon.