What is Inherently Ambiguous Grammar (2)

Duration: 5 min

This video lesson is available to enrolled students.

Return to /learn/UPPSC-POLYTECHNIC-LECTURER-2025-CS/paper-2-compiler-design/grammar-cfg/ambiguity-inherent-amb/asset-what-is-inherently-ambiguous-grammar-2 after enrolling

Inside: a video lesson and guided study material.

Module outline

  1. About Course: UPPSC Course Overview
  2. Interview Preparation & Guidance: Interview Preparation
  3. Paper 1 | General Hindi: भाषा, लिपि, ध्वनि, वर्ण, अक्षर, स्वर, व्यंजन, मात्रा और संयुक्ताक्षर, वर्तनी, वर्ण-विन्यास, अनुस्वार, अनुनासिक, चंद्रबिंदु और ‘र’ के रूप, शब्द, पद और शब्द-भेद, संज्ञा और सर्वनाम, विशेषण और क्रिया, लिंग, वचन, पुरुष और कारक, काल, वाच्य, वाक्य और वाक्य-भेद, वर्णमाला, समास, संधि, Multi-Topic Content (Cross-Concept Material), हिन्दी की ध्वनि और स्वनिम व्यवस्था, प्राचीन और मध्यकालीन भारतीय आर्यभाषाएँ, काव्य के लक्षण, हेतु और प्रयोजन, हिन्दी की रूप रचना, हिन्दी शब्द रचना, हिन्दी साहित्येतिहास दर्शन, भक्तिकालीन काव्यधाराएँ, भारतीय काव्यशास्त्र की परंपरा, भारतीय नवजागरण और स्वाधीनता आंदोलन, अन्य गद्य विधाएँ एवं प्रवासी साहित्य, निर्धारित उपन्यासों का तुलनात्मक अध्ययन, गोदान, हिन्दी कहानी का विकास, स्वातंत्र्योत्तर और नयी कहानी, हिन्दी निबंध का विकास, शुक्लोत्तर निबंध, द्विवेदी और शुक्ल युग के निबंध, हिन्दी की संवैधानिक स्थिति, आधुनिक भारतीय आर्यभाषाएँ और हिन्दी का उद्भव, हिन्दी भाषा प्रयोग के विविध रूप, रीतिकाल, जीवनी, द्विवेदी युग और छायावाद, रीति, वक्रोक्ति और औचित्य सिद्धान्त, शब्दशक्ति और ध्वनि सिद्धान्त, रस सिद्धान्त और साधारणीकरण, उत्तर आधुनिकतावाद, लोहिया दर्शन, हिन्दी उपन्यास का विकास, हिन्दी नवजागरण, अंबेडकर दर्शन, आदिकाल, प्रयोगवाद और नयी कविता, छायावादी काव्य: प्रसाद और निराला, प्रगतिवाद से समकालीन कविता, निर्गुण भक्ति काव्य, द्विवेदीयुगीन काव्य, रीतिकालीन काव्य, आरंभिक हिन्दी उपन्यास, स्वातंत्र्योत्तर उपन्यास, आत्मकथा, स्वाधीनता-पूर्व प्रेमचंदोत्तर उपन्यास, निर्धारित कहानियों का तुलनात्मक अध्ययन, साठोत्तरी नाटक, प्रसाद और प्रसादोत्तर युग के नाटक, भारतेन्दु युगीन नाटक, स्वातंत्र्योत्तर नाटक, भारतेन्दु युगीन निबंध, संस्मरण और रेखाचित्र, व्यंग्य, एक साहित्यिक की डायरी, संस्कृति के चार अध्याय, सगुण भक्ति काव्य, हिन्दी नाटक, एकांकी और रंगमंच, आधुनिक गद्य और हिन्दी नवजागरण, अलंकार सिद्धान्त, हिन्दी आलोचना का विकास, भक्ति आंदोलन, कल्पना, बिम्ब, प्रतीक, मिथक और फंतासी, नयी कविता का विस्तार और साठोत्तरी कविता, उत्तर-छायावादी और प्रगतिवादी काव्य, काव्यगुण और काव्यदोष, प्लेटो, अरस्तू और पाश्चात्य परंपरा, मार्क्सवाद, स्वच्छन्दतावादी काव्यशास्त्र, आधुनिक पाश्चात्य आलोचना, भाषा और भाषा परिवार, देवनागरी लिपि
  4. Paper 2 | General Studies: State Wise GK, Polity, Geography, History, GK- Current Affairs
  5. Paper 1 | Programming Language: Language Design, C Fundamentals, Control Flow, Functions, Arrays & Pointers, Storage Classes, Structures & Enums, DMA, Macros, Scoping & File Handling, OOPS with C++
  6. Paper 1 | Database Management Systems: Basics of DBMS, ER Diagram, Relational Model & Functional Dependencies, Keys & Integrity Constraints, Normalization (1NF - BCNF), Decomposition Properties & 4NF, File Organization & Indexing, Relational Algebra, SQL, Relational Calculus, Transaction Management, Concurrency Control, ORDBMS, NoSQL
  7. Paper 1 | Cyber Security: कंप्यूटर की मूल बातें और हार्डवेयर / Computer Fundamentals and Hardware, प्रत्यक्ष बोध / Literal Comprehension, कंप्यूटर सॉफ्टवेयर / Computer Software, निष्कर्षात्मक बोध / Inferential Comprehension, आलोचनात्मक बोध / Critical Comprehension, इंटरनेट और वर्ल्ड वाइड वेब / Internet and World Wide Web, ई-मेल और ऑनलाइन संचार / Email and Online Communication, साइबर सुरक्षा / Cyber Security, अपशिष्ट प्रबंधन / Waste Management, डिजिटल नैतिकता, बौद्धिक संपदा और समाज / Digital Ethics, IPR and Society, डिजिटल एवं नव माध्यम / Digital and New Media, क्लाउड और वितरित कंप्यूटिंग / Cloud and Distributed Computing, शोध नैतिकता / Research Ethics, उभरती प्रौद्योगिकियाँ / Emerging Technologies, शिक्षा और शासन में ICT / ICT in Education and Governance, Society, Law & Ethics, Cyber Threats and Malware Attacks, Role of Internet and Web Services, Security in Mobile and Wireless Computing, Electronic Data Interchange and E-Commerce, Physical Security and Cryptography Basics, Intrusion Detection Systems (IDS), Cyber Safety and Security, Ethical Hacking
  8. Paper 1 | Computer Organization and Architecture: Basics of COA, Programming the Basic Computer, Cache Memory Organization, Input Output Organisation, Instr Formats & Modes, Register Transfer and Microoperations, Control Unit Design
  9. Paper 1 | Computer Networks: Introduction to CN, Data Communication, DLL: Access Control, DLL: Flow Control, DLL: Error Control, DLL: Framing, Data Link Layer - Ethernet, Net Layer: IPv4 & Proto, Net Layer: IP Addressing, Net Layer:Routing Protocol, Transport Layer Services, TL: Congestion & UDP, Application Layer, Hardware basics, Network Security
  10. Paper 1 | Design and Analysis of Algorithms: Algorithm Analysis, Time Complexity Analysis, Sorting Algorithms, Greedy Algorithms, Dynamic Programming, Minimum Spanning Trees, Shortest Path Algos, Advanced Algorithms
  11. Paper 1 | Data Structures: Introduction to DS, Array, Linked List, Stack, Queue, Tree, Graphs, Hashing
  12. Paper 1 | Discrete Structures and Theory of Logic: क्रमचय, संचय एवं प्रायिकता / Permutation, Combination and Probability, Set Theory, Relations, Functions, Propositional and Predicate Logic, Graph Theory, Group Theory
  13. Paper 1 | Software Project Management: Software Project Management
  14. Paper 2 | Operating Systems: Introduction to OS, Process Management, CPU Scheduling, Process Synchronization, Threads & Process Creation, Deadlock, Memory Management, Virtual Memory, Disc Scheduling, File Management, Unix OS, Linux OS, Security
  15. Paper 2 | Compiler Design: Intro to Compilers, Lexical Analysis, Grammar & CFG, Syntax Analysis: Top-Down, Syntax Analysis: Bottom-Up, Semantic Analysis & SDT, Intermediate Code Gen, Code Optimization, Run Time Environment, Introduction to TOC, Deterministic FA (DFA), Non-Deterministic FA, Regular Expressions, Pushdown Automata & CFG, Complexity Theory
  16. Paper 2 | Artificial Intelligence & High Performance Computing: Approaches to AI, Search Algorithms, Game Playing, Knowledge Representation, Planning, Multi Agent Systems, Natural Language Processing, Emerging Tech Trends
  17. Paper 2 | Image Processing: Digital Image Fundamentals, Image Enhancement, Image Restoration, Color Image Processing, Image Compression
  18. Paper 2 | Software Engineering: Fundamentals of Software Engineering, Software Requirements and Quality Assurance, Software Design, Estimation and Metrics, Software Testing, Software Maintenance and Configuration Management
  19. Paper 2 | Computer Graphics: Basics of Computer Graphics, 2-D Geometrical Transforms and Viewing, 3-D Object Representation, Geometric Transformations and Viewing
  20. Paper 2 | Web Technologies: Website, Browser & Services, Internet Fundamentals, Web Design & Development, Protocols & Services, Web Publishing & Hosting, Server Side & Security, Emerging Technologies, HTML Basics, JavaScript-Basics, Java
  21. Paper 2 | Soft Computing: Fuzzy Sets, Artificial Neural Networks, Genetic Algorithms
  22. Paper 2 | Distributed System: Distributed Systems
  23. UPPSC Live Class Recordings: UPPSC Polytechnic Lecturer 2025 (CS)
  24. Previous Year Papers:
  25. Mock Test:
AI summary & chapters

AI Summary

An AI-generated summary of this video lecture.

This educational video lecture focuses on the theoretical concepts of ambiguity within the domain of Formal Languages and Automata Theory, specifically concerning Context-Free Grammars (CFGs). The session begins by introducing the concept of "inherently ambiguous" Context-Free Languages (CFLs). The on-screen text explains that a CFL is called inherently ambiguous if there exists no unambiguous Context-Free Grammar (CFG) capable of generating that specific language. This concept is attributed to a proof by Rohit Parikh in 1961. A concrete mathematical example is provided on the slide: the language defined as the union of two sets, `{a^n b^m c^m d^n} U {a^n b^n c^m d^m}`. Additionally, the slide presents a crucial rule regarding recursion: a grammar that is both left and right recursive is always ambiguous. However, it clarifies that the converse is not true; an ambiguous grammar does not necessarily have to be both left and right recursive.

The instructor then moves to a whiteboard to provide a formal definition of ambiguous grammar. The text on the board states: "The grammar G is said to be ambiguous if there more than one derivation tree for any input string." It further clarifies that if there exist more than one Leftmost Derivation Tree (LMDT) or Rightmost Derivation Tree (RMDT), the grammar is considered ambiguous. To illustrate this, the grammar `S -> aS/Sa/a` is written on the board. The instructor draws a diagram to visualize the concept, showing two different grammars, labeled AG1 and G2, both generating the same language L. He writes `AG1` and `G2` and draws arrows pointing to `L`, circling the grammars to emphasize that distinct grammars can produce the same language.

Later in the video, the presentation returns to the initial slide. The instructor uses a red marker to underline key phrases to emphasize their importance. He underlines "inherently ambiguous," "no unambiguous CFG," "corresponding CFL," and "Rohit Parikh 1961." He also underlines the sentence "Grammar which is both left and right recursive is always ambiguous." Finally, a new slide appears displaying a complex set of production rules: `S -> SAB / e`, `A -> AaB / a`, and `B -> AS / b`. The instructor writes `S -> SAB` and `S -> AAS` on the whiteboard, likely setting up an analysis of this specific grammar's properties.

Chapters

  1. 0:00 – 2:00 00:00-02:00

    The video opens with a slide defining "inherently ambiguous" CFLs, citing Rohit Parikh (1961) and the example `{a^n b^m c^m d^n} U {a^n b^n c^m d^m}`. It also states that left and right recursive grammars are always ambiguous. The instructor then switches to a whiteboard, defining ambiguous grammar as having more than one derivation tree (LMDT or RMDT) for an input string. He writes the example `S -> aS/Sa/a` and draws a diagram showing two grammars (AG1, G2) generating the same language L.

  2. 2:00 – 4:33 02:00-04:33

    The lecture returns to the slide, where the instructor underlines key terms like "inherently ambiguous," "no unambiguous CFG," and "Rohit Parikh 1961" to reinforce the definitions. He also underlines the rule about left and right recursive grammars. The session concludes with a new slide showing production rules `S -> SAB / e`, `A -> AaB / a`, `B -> AS / b`. The instructor writes `S -> SAB` and `S -> AAS` on the board, preparing to analyze this new grammar.

The lecture systematically builds the understanding of ambiguity by first defining inherent ambiguity in languages, then defining ambiguity in grammars, and finally providing examples and rules. It connects the theoretical proof by Rohit Parikh with practical definitions involving derivation trees and recursion, culminating in the analysis of specific production rules. The visual progression from slide text to whiteboard diagrams helps clarify the abstract concepts of derivation trees and language generation.

Loading lesson…