Statements: All men are vertebrates. Some mammals are vertebrates.…

2024

Statements:
All men are vertebrates.
Some mammals are vertebrates.

Conclusions:
(1) All men are mammals.
(2) All mammals are men.
(3) Some vertebrates are mammals.
(4) All vertebrates are men.

  1. A.

    Only (4)

  2. B.

    Only (2)

  3. C.

    Only (3)

  4. D.

    Only (1)

Attempted by 2 students.

Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: C

Concept: In a syllogism, a conclusion only follows if it can be validly derived from the given statements. A universal affirmative statement ('All X are Y') cannot be reversed into 'All Y are X' — that reversal is an invalid conversion. A particular affirmative statement ('Some X are Y'), however, always converts validly into 'Some Y are X', because asserting an overlap between two classes is symmetric.

Application: Premise 1 places men entirely inside vertebrates ('All men are vertebrates'). Premise 2 asserts that mammals and vertebrates overlap ('Some mammals are vertebrates'). Checking each conclusion against these:

  1. All men are mammals — no premise relates men to mammals directly, so this cannot be derived.

  2. All mammals are men — the same issue in the other direction; nothing connects mammals to men.

  3. Some vertebrates are mammals — this is exactly the valid conversion of 'Some mammals are vertebrates', since a particular affirmative converts symmetrically. This follows.

  4. All vertebrates are men — this would require reversing the universal statement 'All men are vertebrates', which is an invalid conversion; other vertebrates need not be men.

Cross-check: Drawing the classes as circles confirms this: vertebrates contains men entirely, and mammals overlaps vertebrates in some region — but that region need not touch the men-circle at all. The only relationship guaranteed in every such diagram is the overlap between vertebrates and mammals stated in reverse, i.e., conclusion (3).

Result: Only conclusion (3) follows.

Explore the full course: Infosys Preparation

Loading lesson…