Statements: All the locks are keys. All the keys are bats. Some watches are…
2024
Statements:
All the locks are keys.
All the keys are bats.
Some watches are bats.
Conclusions:
A. Some bats are locks.
B. Some watches are keys.
C. All the keys are locks.
- A.
Only A
- B.
Only B
- C.
Only A and B
- D.
Only A and C
Attempted by 2 students.
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: A
Concept: When two universal statements chain (All A are B, All B are C), the categories nest as A within B within C. Two rules apply: (1) Hypothetical syllogism — the chain also gives 'All A are C'. (2) Conversion — a universal 'All A are B' licenses only the particular 'Some B are A', never the full reverse 'All B are A'. A lone 'Some X are Y' statement only guarantees overlap between X and Y — nothing about a third category unless the statement names it.
Application:
Chain the two universal statements: Locks within Keys within Bats, so every lock is necessarily a bat — 'All locks are bats' holds in every valid diagram.
Convert that result: 'All locks are bats' converts to 'Some bats are locks' — this is Conclusion A, and it follows.
Conclusion B claims watches overlap keys. The only given fact about watches is 'some watches are bats' — this places watches somewhere inside the bats region, but a valid diagram exists where that overlap sits entirely outside the keys sub-region, so the overlap with keys is not guaranteed.
Conclusion C reverses the first statement into 'All keys are locks.' Reversing a universal statement is invalid — conversion only licenses the weaker particular form, never a full reversal to 'All'.
Cross-check: Draw the two valid possibility diagrams for these statements (Bats as the outermost circle, Keys nested inside it, Locks nested inside Keys, and a small Watches circle overlapping only Bats in one diagram and overlapping Bats and Keys in the other). Conclusion A is true in BOTH diagrams, so it is definite. Conclusion B is true in only one of the two diagrams, so it is not definite. Conclusion C does not hold in either diagram, and nothing in the statements forces Keys and Locks to coincide, so it is not guaranteed to follow. Hence only Conclusion A follows.
Answer: Only A.