Direction: Fill in the blank in the following sentence with the help of the…
20242023
Direction: Fill in the blank in the following sentence with the help of the options that follow.
________ have donated clothes to many refugees.
- A.
Akash, you and I
- B.
You, Akash and I
- C.
I, you and Akash
- D.
I, Akash and you
Attempted by 17 students.
Show answer & explanation
Correct answer: B
Concept: When singular personal pronouns of different persons are combined as the subject of a sentence, the standard convention (widely known as the '231' rule) is to state them in the order second person, then third person, then first person — for example, 'You, he and I ...'. The one exception is when the sentence expresses a mistake or fault being admitted by the speaker; in that case the order switches to first person, second person, third person ('123').
Application:
In the blank, the pronoun 'you' is second person, the name 'Akash' stands in for the third person, and 'I' is first person. Since the sentence is a neutral, positive statement (donating clothes to refugees) and not an admission of fault, the 231 order applies: second person, third person, first person gives 'You, Akash and I'.
Cross-check:
This matches the standard textbook examples of the rule, such as 'You, he and I won the prize for essay writing' and 'You, Mohan and I will watch a movie tonight' — in both, the second person precedes the third person, which precedes the first person. The remaining option orderings either put the third person before the second person, or open with the first person (which would only be correct if the speaker were confessing a mistake), so none of them fit this sentence.
Complete sentence: You, Akash and I have donated clothes to many refugees.