Hari (H), Gita (G), Irfan (I) and Saira (S) are siblings (i.e. brothers and…

2010

Hari (H), Gita (G), Irfan (I) and Saira (S) are siblings (i.e. brothers and sisters). All were born on 1st january. The age difference between any two successive siblings (that is born one after another) is less than 3 years. Given the following facts:

i. Hari’s age + Gita’s age > Irfan’s age + Saira’s age

ii. The age difference between Gita and Saira is 1 year. However Gita is not the oldest and Saira is not the youngest.

iii. There are no twins.

In what order were they born (oldest first)?

  1. A.

    HSIG

  2. B.

    SGHI

  3. C.

    IGSH

  4. D.

    IHSG

Attempted by 31 students.

Show answer & explanation

Correct answer: B

Answer: SGHI

Explanation:

  • Each successive sibling is less than 3 years younger, so each adjacent age gap is either 1 or 2 years. Because Gita and Saira differ by exactly 1 year, they must be adjacent in the birth order.

  • Gita is not the oldest and Saira is not the youngest. Therefore the adjacent Gita–Saira pair can appear only in these placements: S G _ _, _ G S _, or _ _ S G.

  • Model the four ages as positions 1..4 with ages: x, x - a, x - a - b, x - a - b - c where a, b, c are each 1 or 2 (the successive gaps).

  • Check each feasible adjacency placement:

    • S G H I (positions 1,2,3,4 = S,G,H,I): the inequality H + G > I + S becomes (x - a - b) + (x - a) > (x - a - b - c) + x, which simplifies to a < c. Since Gita and Saira differ by 1 year, a = 1, so we need c = 2. This is achievable. Example: choose gaps a = 1, b = 1, c = 2 and x = 10, giving ages S = 10, G = 9, H = 8, I = 6; then H + G = 17 > I + S = 16.

    • I G S H (positions 1,2,3,4 = I,G,S,H): adjacency forces b = 1. The inequality H + G > I + S reduces to -(a + c) > 0, which is impossible because a and c are at least 1. So no allowed gaps can satisfy the inequality here.

    • I H S G (positions 1,2,3,4 = I,H,S,G): adjacency forces c = 1. The inequality again reduces to -(a + c) > 0, impossible for a, c ≥ 1, so this ordering cannot work.

    • H S I G places Gita and Saira non-adjacent, contradicting the given 1-year difference, so it is invalid.

  • Therefore the only ordering consistent with all constraints is S G H I.

Explore the full course: Gate Guidance By Sanchit Sir